Episode 153: “Heroes and Villains” by the Beach Boys

A History of Rock Music in 500 Songs
A History of Rock Music in 500 Songs
Episode 153: "Heroes and Villains" by the Beach Boys

The Beach Boys (plus Brian's dog Banana) lying on top of one another, with pillows, in a tent. smiling. Brian and Carl are on the bottom of the pile, Banana is at the top

Episode one hundred and fifty-three of A History of Rock Music in Five Hundred Songs looks at “Heroes and Villains” by the Beach Boys, and the collapse of the Smile album. Click the full post to read liner notes, links to more information, and a transcript of the episode.

Patreon backers also have a sixteen-minute bonus episode available, on “I Had Too Much to Dream Last Night” by the Electric Prunes.

Tilt Araiza has assisted invaluably by doing a first-pass edit, and will hopefully be doing so from now on. Check out Tilt’s irregular podcasts at http://www.podnose.com/jaffa-cakes-for-proust and http://sitcomclub.com/


There is no Mixcloud this week, because there were too many Beach Boys songs in the episode.

I used many resources for this episode. As well as the books I referred to in all the Beach Boys episodes, listed below, I used Domenic Priore’s book Smile: The Story of Brian Wilson’s Lost Masterpiece and Richard Henderson’s 33 1/3 book on Van Dyke Parks’ Song Cycle.

Stephen McParland has published many, many books on the California surf and hot-rod music scenes, including several on both the Beach Boys and Gary Usher.  His books can be found at https://payhip.com/CMusicBooks

Andrew Doe’s Bellagio 10452 site is an invaluable resource.

Jon Stebbins’ The Beach Boys FAQ is a good balance between accuracy and readability.

And Philip Lambert’s Inside the Music of Brian Wilson is an excellent, though sadly out of print, musicological analysis of Wilson’s music from 1962 through 67.

Catch a Wave: The Rise, Fall, and Redemption of the Beach Boys’ Brian Wilson by Peter Ames Carlin is the best biography of Wilson.

I have also referred to Brian Wilson’s autobiography, I Am Brian Wilson, and to Mike Love’s, Good Vibrations: My Life as a Beach Boy.

As a good starting point for the Beach Boys’ music in general, I would recommend this budget-priced three-CD set, which has a surprisingly good selection of their material on it, including the single version of “Heroes and Villains”.

The box set The Smile Sessions  contains an attempt to create a finished album from the unfinished sessions, plus several CDs of outtakes and session material.


[Opening — “intro to the album” studio chatter into “Our Prayer”]
Before I start, I’d just like to note that this episode contains some discussion of mental illness, including historical negative attitudes towards it, so you may want to check the transcript or skip this one if that might be upsetting.
In November and December 1966, the filmmaker David Oppenheim and the conductor and composer Leonard Bernstein collaborated on a TV film called “Inside Pop: The Rock Revolution”.  The film was an early attempt at some of the kinds of things this podcast is doing, looking at how music and social events interact and evolve, though it was dealing with its present rather than the past.
The film tried to cast as wide a net as possible in its fifty-one minutes. It looked at two bands from Manchester — the Hollies and Herman’s Hermits — and how the people identified as their leaders, “Herman” (or Peter Noone) and Graham Nash, differed on the issue of preventing war:
[Excerpt: Inside Pop, the Rock Revolution]
And it made a star of East Coast teenage singer-songwriter Janis Ian with her song about interracial relationships, “Society’s Child”:
[Excerpt: Janis Ian, “Society’s Child”]
And Bernstein spends a significant time, as one would expect, analysing the music of the Beatles and to a lesser extent the Stones, though they don’t appear in the show. Bernstein does a lot to legitimise the music just by taking it seriously as a subject for analysis, at a time when most wouldn’t:
[Excerpt: Leonard Bernstein talking about “She Said She Said”]
You can’t see it, obviously, but in the clip that’s from, as the Beatles recording is playing, Bernstein is conducting along with the music, as he would a symphony orchestra, showing where the beats are falling.
But of course, given that this was filmed in the last two months of 1966, the vast majority of the episode is taken up with musicians from the centre of the music world at that time, LA.
The film starts with Bernstein interviewing Tandyn Almer,  a jazz-influenced songwriter who had recently written the big hit “Along Comes Mary” for The Association:
[Excerpt: Inside Pop: The Rock Revolution]
It featured interviews with Roger McGuinn, and with the protestors at the Sunset Strip riots which were happening contemporaneously with the filming:
[Excerpt: Inside Pop: The Rock Revolution]
Along with Frank Zappa’s rather acerbic assessment of the potential of the youth revolutionaries:
[Excerpt: Inside Pop: The Rock Revolution]
And ended (other than a brief post-commercial performance over the credits by the Hollies) with a performance by Tim Buckley, whose debut album, as we heard in the last episode, had featured Van Dyke Parks and future members of the Mothers of Invention and Buffalo Springfield:
[Excerpt: Inside Pop: The Rock Revolution]
But for many people the highlight of the film was the performance that came right before Buckley’s, film of Brian Wilson playing a new song from the album he was working on. One thing I should note — many sources say that the voiceover here is Bernstein. My understanding is that Bernstein wrote and narrated the parts of the film he was himself in, and Oppenheim did all the other voiceover writing and narration, but that Oppenheim’s voice is similar enough to Bernstein’s that people got confused about this:
[Excerpt: Inside Pop: The Rock Revolution]
That particular piece of footage was filmed in December 1966, but it wasn’t broadcast until April the twenty-fifth, 1967, an eternity in mid-sixties popular music. When it was broadcast, that album still hadn’t come out.
Precisely one week later, the Beach Boys’ publicist Derek Taylor announced that it never would:
[Excerpt: Brian Wilson, “Surf’s Up”]
One name who has showed up in a handful of episodes recently, but who we’ve not talked that much about, is Van Dyke Parks. And in a story with many, many, remarkable figures, Van Dyke Parks may be one of the most remarkable of all. Long before he did anything that impinges on the story of rock music, Parks had lived the kind of life that would be considered unbelievable were it to be told as fiction.
Parks came from a family that mixed musical skill, political progressiveness, and achievement. His mother was a scholar of Hebrew, while his father was a neurologist, the first doctor to admit Black patients to a white Southern hospital, and had paid his way through college leading a dance band.
Parks’ father was also, according to the 33 1/3 book on Song Cycle, a member of “John Philip Sousa’s Sixty Silver Trumpets”, but literally every reference I can find to Sousa leading a band of that name goes back to that book, so I’ve no idea what he was actually a member of, but we can presume he was a reasonable musician.
Young Van Dyke started playing the clarinet at four, and was also a singer from a very early age, as well as playing several other instruments. He went to the American Boychoir School in Princeton, to study singing, and while there he sang with Toscaninni, Thomas Beecham, and other immensely important conductors of the era.
He also had a very special accompanist for one Christmas carolling session. The choir school was based in Princeton, and one of the doors he knocked on while carolling was that of Princeton’s most famous resident, Albert Einstein, who heard the young boy singing “Silent Night”, and came out with his violin and played along.
Young Van Dyke was only interested in music, but he was also paying the bills for his music tuition himself — he had a job. He was a TV star. From the age of ten, he started getting roles in TV shows — he played the youngest son in the 1953 sitcom Bonino, about an opera singer, which flopped because it aired opposite the extremely popular Jackie Gleason Show. He would later also appear in that show, as one of several child actors who played the character of Little Tommy Manicotti, and he made a number of other TV appearances, as well as having a small role in Grace Kelly’s last film, The Swan, with Alec Guinness and Louis Jourdain.
But he never liked acting, and just did it to pay for his education. He gave it up when he moved on to the Carnegie Institute, where he majored in composition and performance. But then in his second year, his big brother Carson asked him to drop out and move to California.
Carson Parks had been part of the folk scene in California for a few years at this point. He and a friend had formed a duo called the Steeltown Two, but then both of them had joined the folk group the Easy Riders, a group led by Terry Gilkyson.
Before Carson Parks joined, the Easy Riders had had a big hit with their version of “Marianne”, a calypso originally by the great calypsonian Roaring Lion:
[Excerpt: The Easy Riders, “Marianne”]
They hadn’t had many other hits, but their songs became hits for other people — Gilkyson wrote several big hits for Frankie Laine, and the Easy Riders were the backing vocalists on Dean Martin’s recording of a song they wrote, “Memories are Made of This”:
[Excerpt: Dean Martin and the Easy Riders, “Memories are Made of This”]
Carson Parks hadn’t been in the group at that point — he only joined after they’d stopped having success — and eventually the group had split up. He wanted to revive his old duo, the Steeltown Two, and persuaded his family to let his little brother Van Dyke drop out of university and move to California to be the other half of the duo. He wanted Van Dyke to play guitar, while he played banjo. Van Dyke had never actually played guitar before, but as Carson Parks later said “in 90 days, he knew more than most folks know after many years!”
Van Dyke moved into an apartment adjoining his brother’s, owned by Norm Botnick, who had until recently been the principal viola player in a film studio orchestra, before the film studios all simultaneously dumped their in-house orchestras in the late fifties, so was a more understanding landlord than most when it came to the lifestyles of musicians. Botnick’s sons, Doug and Bruce, later went into sound engineering — we’ve already encountered Bruce Botnick in the episode on the Doors, and he will be coming up again in the future.
The new Steeltown Two didn’t make any records, but they developed a bit of a following in the coffeehouses, and they also got a fair bit of session work, mostly through Terry Gilkyson, who was by that point writing songs for Disney and would hire them to play on sessions for his songs. And it was Gilkyson who both brought Van Dyke Parks the worst news of his life to that point, and in doing so also had him make his first major mark on music.
Gilkyson was the one who informed Van Dyke that another of his brothers, Benjamin Riley Parks, had died in what was apparently a car accident. I say it was apparently an accident because Benjamin Riley Parks was at the time working for the US State Department, and there is apparently also some evidence that he was assassinated in a Cold War plot.
Gilkyson also knew that neither Van Dyke nor Carson Parks had much money, so in order to help them afford black suits and plane tickets to and from the funeral, Gilkyson hired Van Dyke to write the arrangement for a song he had written for an upcoming Disney film:
[Excerpt: Jungle Book soundtrack, “The Bare Necessities”]
The Steeltown Two continued performing, and soon became known as the Steeltown Three, with the addition of a singer named Pat Peyton. The Steeltown Three recorded two singles, “Rock Mountain”, under that group name:
[Excerpt: The Steeltown Three, “Rock Mountain”]
And a version of “San Francisco Bay” under the name The South Coasters, which I’ve been unable to track down. Then the three of them, with the help of Terry Gilkyson, formed a larger group in the style of the New Christy Minstrels — the Greenwood County Singers. Indeed, Carson Parks would later claim that  Gilkyson had had the idea first — that he’d mentioned that he’d wanted to put together a group like that to Randy Sparks, and Sparks had taken the idea and done it first.
The Greenwood County Singers had two minor hot one hundred hits, only one of them while Van Dyke was in the band — “The New ‘Frankie and Johnny’ Song”, a rewrite by Bob Gibson and Shel Silverstein of the old traditional song “Frankie and Johnny”:
[Excerpt: The Greenwood County Singers, “The New Frankie and Johnny Song”]
They also recorded several albums together, which gave Van Dyke the opportunity to practice his arrangement skills, as on this version of  “Vera Cruz” which he arranged:
[Excerpt: The Greenwood County Singers, “Vera Cruz”]
Some time before their last album, in 1965, Van Dyke left the Greenwood County Singers, and was replaced by Rick Jarrard, who we’ll also be hearing more about in future episodes. After that album, the group split up, but Carson Parks would go on to write two big hits in the next few years. The first and biggest was a song he originally wrote for a side project. His future wife Gaile Foote was also a Greenwood County Singer, and the two of them thought they might become folk’s answer to Sonny and Cher or Nino Tempo and April Stevens:
[Excerpt: Carson and Gaile, “Somethin’ Stupid”]
That obviously became a standard after it was covered by Frank and Nancy Sinatra. Carson Parks also wrote “Cab Driver”, which in 1968 became the last top thirty hit for the Mills Brothers, the 1930s vocal group we talked about way way back in episode six:
[Excerpt: The Mills Brothers, “Cab Driver”]
Meanwhile Van Dyke Parks was becoming part of the Sunset Strip rock and roll world. Now, until we get to 1967, Parks has something of a tangled timeline. He worked with almost every band around LA in a short period, often working with multiple people simultaneously, and nobody was very interested in keeping detailed notes. So I’m going to tell this as a linear story, but be aware it’s very much not — things I say in five minutes might happen after, or in the same week as, things I say in half an hour.
At some point in either 1965 or 1966 he joined the Mothers of Invention for a brief while. Nobody is entirely sure when this was, and whether it was before or after their first album. Some say it was in late 1965, others in August 1966, and even the kind of fans who put together detailed timelines are none the wiser, because no recordings have so far surfaced of Parks with the band. Either is plausible, and the Mothers went through a variety of keyboard players at this time — Zappa had turned to his jazz friend Don Preston, but found Preston was too much of a jazzer and told him to come back when he could play “Louie Louie” convincingly, asked Mac Rebennack to be in the band but sacked him pretty much straight away for drug use, and eventually turned to Preston again once Preston had learned to rock and roll. Some time in that period, Van Dyke Parks was a Mother, playing electric harpsichord. He may even have had more than one stint in the group — Zappa said “Van Dyke Parks played electric harpsichord in and out.”
It seems likely, though, that it was in summer of 1966, because in an interview published in Teen Beat Magazine in December 66, but presumably conducted a few months prior, Zappa was asked to describe the band members in one word each and replied:
Van Dyke—Pinocchio
I don’t know about the rest of the group—I don’t even know about these guys.”
Sources differ as to why Parks didn’t remain in the band — Parks has said that he quit after a short time because he didn’t like being shouted at, while Zappa said “Van Dyke was not a reliable player. He didn’t make it to rehearsal on time and things like that.”
Both may be true of course, though I’ve not heard anyone else ever criticise Parks for his reliability. But then also Zappa had much more disciplinarian standards than most rock band leaders.
It’s possibly either through Zappa that he met Tom Wilson, or through Tom Wilson that he met Frank Zappa, but either way Parks, like the Mothers of Invention, was signed to MGM records in 1966, where he released two solo singles co-produced by Wilson and an otherwise obscure figure named Tim Alvorado. The first was “Number Nine”, which we heard last week, backed with “Do What You Wanta”:
[Excerpt: Van Dyke Parks, “Do What You Wanta”]
At least one source I’ve read says that the lyrics to “Do What You Wanta” were written not by Parks but by his friend Danny Hutton, but it’s credited as a Parks solo composition on the label.
It was after that that the Van Dyke Parks band — or as they were sometimes billed, just The Van Dyke Parks formed, as we discussed last episode, based around Parks, Steve Stills, and Steve Young, and they performed a handful of shows with bass player Bobby Rae and drummer Walt Sparman, playing a mix of original material, primarily Parks’ songs, and covers of things like “Dancing in the Street”. The one contemporaneous review of a live show I’ve seen talks about  the girls in the audience screaming and how “When rhythm guitarist Steve Stillman imitated the Barry McGuire emotional scene, they almost went wiggy”.
But The Van Dyke Parks soon split up, and Parks the individual recorded his second single, “Come to the Sunshine”:
[Excerpt: Van Dyke Parks, “Come to the Sunshine”]
Around the time he left the Greenwood County Singers, Van Dyke Parks also met Brian Wilson for the first time, when David Crosby took him up to Wilson’s house to hear an acetate of the as-yet-unreleased track “Sloop John B”. Parks was impressed by Wilson’s arrangement techniques, and in particular the way he was orchestrating instrumental combinations that you couldn’t do with a standard live room setup, that required overdubbing and close-micing. He said later “The first stuff I heard indicated this kind of curiosity for the recording experience, and when I went up to see him in ’65 I don’t even think he had the voices on yet, but I heard that long rotational breathing, that long flute ostinato at the beginning… I knew this man was a great musician.”
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “Sloop John B (instrumental)”]
In most of 1966, though, Parks was making his living as a session keyboard player and arranger, and much of the work he was getting was through Lenny Waronker.
Waronker was a second-generation music industry professional. His father, Si Waronker, had been a violinist in the Twentieth Century Fox studio orchestra before founding Liberty Records (the label which indirectly led to him becoming immortalised in children’s entertainment, when Liberty Records star David Seville named his Chipmunk characters after three Liberty executives, with Simon being Si Waronker’s full forename). The first release on Liberty Records had been a version of “The Girl Upstairs”, an instrumental piece from the Fox film The Seven-Year Itch. The original recording of that track, for the film, had been done by the Twentieth Century Fox Orchestra, written and conducted by Alfred Newman, the musical director for Fox:
[Excerpt: Alfred Newman, “The Girl Upstairs”]
Liberty’s soundalike version was conducted by Newman’s brother Lionel, a pianist at the studio who later became Fox’s musical director for TV, just as his brother was for film, but who also wrote many film scores himself.
Another Newman brother, Emil, was also a film composer, but the fourth brother, Irving, had gone into medicine instead. However, Irving’s son Randy wanted to follow in the family business, and he and Lenny Waronker, who was similarly following his own father by working for Liberty Records’ publishing subsidiary Metric Music, had been very close friends ever since High School. Waronker got Newman signed to Metric Music, where he wrote “They Tell Me It’s Summer” for the Fleetwoods:
[Excerpt: The Fleetwoods, “They Tell Me It’s Summer”]
Newman also wrote and recorded a single of his own in 1962, co-produced by Pat Boone:
[Excerpt: Randy Newman, “Golden Gridiron Boy”]
Before deciding he wasn’t going to make it as a singer and had better just be a professional songwriter.
But by 1966 Waronker had moved on from Metric to Warner Brothers, and become a junior A&R man. And he was put in charge of developing the artists that Warners had acquired when they had bought up a small label, Autumn Records. Autumn Records was a San Francisco-based label whose main producer, Sly Stone, had now moved on to other things after producing the hit record “Laugh Laugh” for the Beau Brummels:
[Excerpt: The Beau Brummels, “Laugh Laugh”]
The Beau Brummels  had had another hit after that and were the main reason that Warners had bought the label, but their star was fading a little. Stone had also been mentoring several other groups, including the Tikis and the Mojo Men, who all had potential. Waronker gathered around himself a sort of brains trust of musicians who he trusted as songwriters, arrangers, and pianists — Randy Newman, the session pianist Leon Russell, and Van Dyke Parks. Their job was to revitalise the career of the Beau Brummels, and to make both the Tikis and the Mojo Men into successes. The tactic they chose was, in Waronker’s words, “Go in with a good song and weird it out.”
The first good song they tried weirding out was in late 1966, when Leon Russell came up with a clarinet-led arrangement of Paul Simon’s “59th Street Bridge Song (Feeling Groovy)” for the Tikis, who performed it but who thought that their existing fanbase wouldn’t accept something so different, so it was put out under another name, suggested by Parks, Harpers Bizarre:
[Excerpt: Harpers Bizarre, “Feeling Groovy”]
Waronker said of Parks and Newman “They weren’t old school guys. They were modern characters but they had old school values regarding certain records that needed to be made, certain artists who needed to be heard regardless. So there was still that going on. The fact that ‘Feeling Groovy’ was a number 10 hit nationwide and ‘Sit Down, I Think I Love You’  made the Top 30 on Western regional radio, that gave us credibility within the company. One hit will do wonders, two allows you to take chances.”
We heard “Sit Down, I Think I Love You” last episode — that’s the song by Parks’ old friend Stephen Stills that Parks arranged for the Mojo Men:
[Excerpt: The Mojo Men, “Sit Down, I Think I Love You”]
During 1966 Parks also played on Tim Buckley’s first album, as we also heard last episode:
[Excerpt: Tim Buckley, “Aren’t You the Girl?”]
And he also bumped into Brian Wilson on occasion, as they were working a lot in the same studios and had mutual friends like Loren Daro and Danny Hutton, and he suggested the cello part on “Good Vibrations”. Parks also played keyboards on “5D” by the Byrds:
[Excerpt: The Byrds, “5D (Fifth Dimension)”]
And on the Spirit of ’67 album for Paul Revere and the Raiders, produced by the Byrds’ old producer Terry Melcher. Parks played keyboards on much of the album, including the top five hit “Good Thing”:
[Excerpt: Paul Revere and the Raiders, “Good Thing”]
But while all this was going on, Parks was also working on what would become the work for which he was best known. As I’ve said, he’d met Brian Wilson on a few occasions, but it wasn’t until summer 1966 that the two were formally introduced by Terry Melcher, who knew that Wilson needed a new songwriting collaborator, now Tony Asher’s sabbatical from his advertising job was coming to an end, and that Wilson wanted someone who could do work that was a bit more abstract than the emotional material that he had been writing with Asher.
Melcher invited both of them to a party at his house on Cielo Drive — a house which would a few years later become notorious — which was also attended by many of the young Hollywood set of the time. Nobody can remember exactly who was at the party, but Parks thinks it was people like Jack Nicholson and Peter and Jane Fonda.
Parks and Wilson hit it off, with Wilson saying later “He seemed like a really articulate guy, like he could write some good lyrics”. Parks on the other hand was delighted to find that Wilson “liked Les Paul, Spike Jones, all of these sounds that I liked, and he was doing it in a proactive way.”
Brian suggested Parks write the finished lyrics for “Good Vibrations”, which was still being recorded at this time, and still only had Tony Asher’s dummy lyrics,  but Parks was uninterested. He said that it would be best if he and Brian collaborate together on something new from scratch, and Brian agreed.
The first time Parks came to visit Brian at Brian’s home, other than the visit accompanying Crosby the year before, he was riding a motorbike — he couldn’t afford a car — and forgot to bring his driver’s license with him. He was stopped by a police officer who thought he looked too poor to be in the area, but Parks persuaded the police officer that if he came to the door, Brian Wilson would vouch for him. Brian got Van Dyke out of any trouble because the cop’s sister was a Beach Boys fan, so he autographed an album for her.
Brian and Van Dyke talked for a while. Brian asked if Van Dyke needed anything to help his work go smoothly, and Van Dyke said he needed a car. Brian asked what kind. Van Dyke said that Volvos were supposed to be pretty safe. Brian asked how much they cost. Van Dyke said he thought they were about five thousand dollars. Brian called up his office and told them to get a cheque delivered to Van Dyke for five thousand dollars the next day, instantly earning Van Dyke’s loyalty.
After that, they got on with work. To start with, Brian played Van Dyke a melody he’d been working on, a melody based on a descending scale starting on the fourth:
[Plays “Heroes and Villains” melody]
Parks told Wilson that the melody reminded him vaguely of Marty Robbins’ country hit “El Paso” from 1959, a song about a gunfighter, a cantina, and a dancing woman:
[Excerpt: Marty Robbins, “El Paso”]
Wilson said that he had been thinking along the same lines, a sort of old west story, and thought maybe it should be called “Heroes and Villains”. Parks started writing, matching syllables to Wilson’s pre-conceived melody — “I’ve been in this town so long that back in the city I’ve been taken for lost and gone and unknown for a long, long time”
[Excerpt: Brian Wilson and Van Dyke Parks, “Heroes and Villains demo”]
As Parks put it “The engine had started. It was very much ad hoc. Seat of the pants. Extemporaneous values were enforced. Not too much precommitment to ideas. Or, if so, equally pursuing propinquity.”
Slowly, over the next several months, while the five other Beach Boys were touring, Brian and Van Dyke refined their ideas about what the album they were writing, initially called Dumb Angel but soon retitled Smile, should be.
For Van Dyke Parks it was an attempt to make music about America and American mythology. He was disgusted, as a patriot, with the Anglophilia that had swept the music industry since the arrival of the Beatles in America two and a half years earlier, particularly since that had happened so soon after the deaths both of President Kennedy and of Parks’ own brother who was working for the government at the time he died.
So for him, the album was about America, about Plymouth Rock, the Old West, California, and Hawaii. It would be a generally positive version of the country’s myth, though it would of course also acknowledge the bloodshed on which the country had been built:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “Bicycle Rider” section]
As he put it later “I was dead set on centering my life on the patriotic ideal. I was a son of the American revolution, and there was blood on the tracks. Recent blood, and it was still drying. The whole record seemed like a real effort toward figuring out what Manifest Destiny was all about. We’d come as far as we could, as far as Horace Greeley told us to go. And so we looked back and tried to make sense of that great odyssey.”
Brian had some other ideas — he had been studying the I Ching, and Subud, and he wanted to do something about the four classical elements, and something religious — his ideas were generally rather unfocused at the time, and he had far more ideas than he knew what to usefully do with. But he was also happy with the idea of a piece about America, which fit in with his own interest in “Rhapsody in Blue”, a piece that was about America in much the same way.
“Rhapsody in Blue” was an inspiration for Brian primarily in how it weaved together variations on themes. And there are two themes that between them Brian was finding endless variations on. The first theme was a shuffling between two chords a fourth away from each other.
[demonstrates G to C on guitar]
Where these chords are both major, that’s the sequence for “Fire”:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “Mrs. O’Leary’s Cow/Fire”]
For the “Who ran the Iron Horse?” section of “Cabin Essence”:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “Cabinessence”]
For “Vegetables”:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “Vegetables”]
And more.
Sometimes this would be the minor supertonic and dominant seventh of the key, so in C that would be Dm to G7:
[Plays Dm to G7 fingerpicked]
That’s the “bicycle rider” chorus we heard earlier, which was part of a song known as “Roll Plymouth Rock” or “Do You Like Worms”:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “Bicycle Rider”]
But which later became a chorus for “Heroes and Villains”:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “Heroes and Villains”]
But that same sequence is also the beginning of “Wind Chimes”:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “Wind Chimes”]
The “wahalla loo lay” section of “Roll Plymouth Rock”:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “Roll Plymouth Rock”]
And others, but most interestingly, the minor-key rearrangement of “You Are My Sunshine” as “You Were My Sunshine”:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “You Were My Sunshine”]
I say that’s most interesting, because that provides a link to another of the major themes which Brian was wringing every drop out of, a phrase known as “How Dry I Am”, because of its use under those words in an Irving Berlin song, which was a popular barbershop quartet song but is now best known as a signifier of drunkenness in Looney Tunes cartoons:
[Excerpt: Daffy Duck singing “How Dry I Am” ]
The phrase is a common one in early twentieth century music, especially folk and country, as it’s made up of notes in the pentatonic scale — it’s the fifth, first, second, and third of the scale, in that order:
[demonstrates “How Dry I Am”]
And so it’s in the melody to “This Land is Your Land”, for example, a song which is very much in the same spirit of progressive Americana in which Van Dyke Parks was thinking:
[Excerpt: Woody Guthrie, “This Land is Your Land”]
It’s also the start of the original melody of “You Are My Sunshine”:
[Excerpt: Jimmie Davis, “You Are My Sunshine” ]
Brian rearranged that melody when he stuck it into a minor key, so it’s no longer “How Dry I Am” in the Beach Boys version, but if you play the “How Dry I Am” notes in a different rhythm, you get this:
[Plays “He Gives Speeches” melody]
Which is the start of the melody to “He Gives Speeches”:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “He Gives Speeches”]
Play those notes backwards, you get:
[Plays “He Gives Speeches” melody backwards]
Do that and add onto the end a passing sixth and then the tonic, and then you get:
[Plays that]
Which is the vocal *countermelody* in “He Gives Speeches”:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “He Gives Speeches”]
And also turns up in some versions of “Heroes and Villains”:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “Heroes and Villains (alternate version)”]
And so on. Smile was an intricate web of themes and variations, and it incorporated motifs from many sources, both the great American songbook and the R&B of Brian’s youth spent listening to Johnny Otis’ radio show. There were bits of “Gee” by the Crows, of “Twelfth Street Rag”, and of course, given that this was Brian Wilson, bits of Phil Spector. The backing track to the verse of “Heroes and Villains”:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “Heroes and Villains”]
Owed more than a little to a version of “Save the Last Dance For Me” that Spector had produced for Ike and Tina Turner:
[Excerpt: Ike and Tina Turner, “Save the Last Dance For Me”]
While one version of the song “Wonderful” contained a rather out-of-place homage to Etta James and “The Wallflower”:
[Excerpt: “Wonderful (Rock With Me Henry)”]
As the recording continued, it became more and more obvious that the combination of these themes and variations was becoming a little too much for Brian.  Many of the songs he was working on were made up of individual modules that he was planning to splice together the way he had with “Good Vibrations”, and some modules were getting moved between tracks, as he tried to structure the songs in the edit. He’d managed it with “Good Vibrations”, but this was an entire album, not just a single, and it was becoming more and more difficult.
David Anderle, who was heading up the record label the group were looking at starting, would talk about Brian playing him acetates with sections edited together one way, and thinking it was perfect, and obviously the correct way to put them together, the only possible way, and then hearing the same sections edited together in a different way, and thinking *that* was perfect, and obviously the correct way to put them together.
But while a lot of the album was modular, there were also several complete songs with beginnings, middles, ends, and structures, even if they were in several movements. And those songs showed that if Brian could just get the other stuff right, the album could be very, very, special. There was “Heroes and Villains” itself, of course, which kept changing its structure but was still based around the same basic melody and story that Brian and Van Dyke had come up with on their first day working together. There was also “Wonderful”, a beautiful, allusive, song about innocence lost and regained:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “Wonderful”]
And there was CabinEssence, a song which referenced yet another classic song, this time “Home on the Range”, to tell a story of idyllic rural life and of the industrialisation which came with westward expansion:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “CabinEssence”]
The arrangement for that song inspired Van Dyke Parks to make a very astute assessment of Brian Wilson. He said later “He knew that he had to adhere to the counter-culture, and I knew that I had to. I think that he was about as estranged from it as I was…. At the same time, he didn’t want to lose that kind of gauche sensibility that he had. He was doing stuff that nobody would dream of doing. You would never, for example, use one string on a banjo when you had five; it just wasn’t done. But when I asked him to bring a banjo in, that’s what he did. This old-style plectrum thing. One string. That’s gauche.”
Both Parks and Wilson were both drawn to and alienated from the counterculture, but in very different ways, and their different ways of relating to the counterculture created the creative tension that makes the Smile project so interesting. Parks is fundamentally a New Deal Liberal, and was excited by the progresssive nature of the counterculture, but also rather worried about its tendency to throw the baby out with the bathwater, and to ignore the old in pursuit of the new. He was an erudite, cultured, sophisticated man who thought that there was value to be found in the works and attitudes of the past, even as one must look to the future.
He was influenced by the beat poets and the avant garde art of the time, but also said of his folk music period “A harpist would bring his harp with him and he would play and recite a story which had been passed down the generations. This particular legacy continued through Arthurian legend, and then through the Middle Ages, and even into the nineteenth century. With all these songs, half of the story was the lyrics, and the folk songs were very interesting. They were tremendously thought-driven songs; there was nothing confusing about that. Even when the Kingston Trio came out — and Brian has already admitted his debt to the Kingston Trio — ‘Tom Dooley’, the story of a murder most foul ‘MTA’ an urban nightmare — all of this thought-driven music was perfectly acceptable.  It was more than a teenage romantic crisis.”
Brian Wilson, on the other hand, was anything *but* sophisticated. He is a simple man in the best sense of the term — he likes what he likes, doesn’t like what he doesn’t like, and has no pretensions whatsoever about it. He is, at heart, a middle-class middle-American brought up in suburbia, with a taste for steaks and hamburgers, broad physical comedy, baseball, and easy listening music.
Where Van Dyke Parks was talking about “thought-driven music”, Wilson’s music, while thoughtful, has always been driven by feelings first and foremost. Where Parks is influenced by Romantic composers like Gottschalk but is fundamentally a craftsman, a traditionalist, a mason adding his work to a cathedral whose construction started before his birth and will continue after his death, Wilson’s music has none of the stylistic hallmarks of Romantic music, but in its inspiration it is absolutely Romantic — it is the immediate emotional expression of the individual, completely unfiltered. When writing his own lyrics in later years Wilson would come up with everything from almost haiku-like lyrics like “I’m a leaf on a windy day/pretty soon I’ll be blown away/How long with the wind blow?/Until I die” to “He sits behind his microphone/Johnny Carson/He speaks in such a manly tone/Johnny Carson”, depending on whether at the time his prime concern was existential meaninglessness or what was on the TV.
Wilson found the new counterculture exciting, but was also very aware he didn’t fit in. He was developing a new group of friends, the hippest of the hip in LA counterculture circles — the singer Danny Hutton, Mark Volman of the Turtles, the writers Michael Vosse and Jules Siegel, scenester and record executive David Anderle — but there was always the underlying implication that at least some of these people regarded him as, to use an ableist term but one which they would probably have used, an idiot savant. That they thought of him, as his former collaborator Tony Asher would later uncharitably put it, as “a genius musician but an amateur human being”.
So for example when Siegel brought the great postmodern novelist Thomas Pynchon to visit Brian, both men largely sat in silence, unable to speak to each other; Pynchon because he tended to be a reactive person in conversation and would wait for the other person to initiate topics of discussion, Brian because he was so intimidated by Pynchon’s reputation as a great East Coast intellectual that he was largely silent for fear of making a fool of himself.
It was this gaucheness, as Parks eventually put it, and Parks’ understanding that this was actually a quality to be cherished and the key to Wilson’s art, that eventually gave the title to the most ambitious of the complete songs the duo were working on. They had most of the song — a song about the power of music, the concept of enlightenment, and the rise and fall of civilisations:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “Surf’s Up”]
But Parks hadn’t yet quite finished the lyric. The Beach Boys had been off on tour for much of Brian and Van Dyke’s collaboration, and had just got back from their first real tour of the UK, where Pet Sounds had been a smash hit, rather than the middling success it had been in the US, and “Good Vibrations” had just become their first number one single. Brian and Van Dyke played the song for Brian’s brother Dennis, the Beach Boys’ drummer, and the band member most in tune with Brian’s musical ambitions at this time.
Dennis started crying, and started talking about how the British audiences had loved their music, but had laughed at their on-stage striped-shirt uniforms. Parks couldn’t tell if he was crying because of the beauty of the unfinished song, the humiliation he had suffered in Britain, or both. Dennis then asked what the name of the song was, and as Parks later put it “Although it was the most gauche factor, and although maybe Brian thought it was the most dispensable thing, I thought it was very important to continue to use the name and keep the elephant in the room — to keep the surfing image but to sensitise it to new opportunities. One of these would be an eco-consciousness; it would be speaking about the greening of the Earth, aboriginal people, how we had treated the Indians, taking on those things and putting them into the thoughts that come with the music. That was a solution to the relevance of the group, and I wanted the group to be relevant.”
Van Dyke had decided on a title: “Surf’s Up”:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “Surf’s Up”]
As the group were now back from their tour, the focus for recording shifted from the instrumental sessions to vocal ones. Parks had often attended the instrumental sessions, as he was an accomplished musician and arranger himself, and would play on the sessions, but also wanted to learn from what Brian was doing — he’s stated later that some of his use of tuned percussion in the decades since, for example, has come from watching Brian’s work.
But while he was also a good singer, he was not a singer in the same style as the Beach Boys, and they certainly didn’t need his presence at those sessions, so he continued to work on his lyrics, and to do his arrangement and session work for other artists, while they worked in the studio.
He was also, though, starting to distance himself from Brian for other reasons. At the start of the summer, Brian’s eccentricity and whimsy had seemed harmless — indeed, the kind of thing he was doing, such as putting his piano in a sandbox so he could feel the sand with his feet while he wrote, seems very much on a par with Maureen Cleave’s descriptions of John Lennon in the same period. They were two newly-rich, easily bored, young men with low attention spans and high intelligence who could become deeply depressed when understimulated and so would get new ideas into their heads, spend money on their new fads, and then quickly discard them.
But as the summer wore on into autumn and winter, Brian’s behaviour became more bizarre, and to Parks’ eyes more distasteful. We now know that Brian was suffering a period of increasing mental ill-health, something that was probably not helped by the copious intake of cannabis and amphetamines he was using to spur his creativity, but at the time most people around him didn’t realise this, and general knowledge of mental illness was even less than it is today. Brian was starting to do things like insist on holding business meetings in his swimming pool, partly because people wouldn’t be able to spy on him, and partly because he thought people would be more honest if they were in the water.
There were also events like the recording session where Wilson paid for several session musicians, not to play their instruments, but to be recorded while they sat in a pitch-black room and played the party game Lifeboat with Jules Siegel and several of Wilson’s friends, most of whom were stoned and not really understanding what they were doing, while they got angrier and more frustrated.
Alan Jardine — who unlike the Wilson brothers, and even Mike Love to an extent, never indulged in illegal drugs — has talked about not understanding why, in some vocal sessions, Brian would make the group crawl on their hands and knees while making noises like animals:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “Heroes and Villains Part 3 (Animals)”]
As Parks delicately put it “I sensed all that was destructive, so I withdrew from those related social encounters.”
What this meant though was that he was unaware that not all the Beach Boys took the same attitude of complete support for the work he and Brian had been doing that Dennis Wilson — the only other group member he’d met at this point — took.
In particular, Mike Love was not a fan of Parks’ lyrics. As he said later “I called it acid alliteration. The [lyrics are] far out. But do they relate like ‘Surfin’ USA,’ like ‘Fun Fun Fun,’ like ‘California Girls,’ like ‘I Get Around’? Perhaps not! So that’s the distinction. See, I’m into success. These words equal successful hit records; those words don’t”
Now, Love has taken a lot of heat for this over the years, and on an artistic level that’s completely understandable. Parks’ lyrics were, to my mind at least, the best the Beach Boys ever had — thoughtful, intelligent, moving, at times profound, often funny, often beautiful.
But, while I profoundly disagree with Love, I have a certain amount of sympathy for his position. From Love’s perspective, first and foremost, this is his source of income. He was the only one of the Beach Boys to ever have had a day job — he’d worked at his father’s sheet metal company — and didn’t particularly relish the idea of going back to manual labour if the rock star gig dried up. It wasn’t that he was *opposed* to art, of course — he’d written the lyrics to “Good Vibrations”, possibly the most arty rock single released to that point, hadn’t he? — but that had been *commercial* art. It had sold. Was this stuff going to sell? Was he still going to be able to feed his wife and kids?
Also, up until a few months earlier he had been Brian’s principal songwriting collaborator. He was *still* the most commercially successful collaborator Brian had had. From his perspective, this was a partnership, and it was being turned into a dictatorship without him having been consulted. Before, it had been “Mike, can you write some lyrics for this song about cars?”, now it was “Mike, you’re going to sing these lyrics about a crow uncovering a cornfield”.
And not only that, but Mike had not met Brian’s new collaborator, but knew he was hanging round with Brian’s new druggie friends. And Brian was behaving increasingly weirdly, which Mike put down to the influence of the drugs and these new friends.
It can’t have helped that at the same time the group’s publicist, Derek Taylor, was heavily pushing the line “Brian Wilson is a genius”. This was causing Brian some distress — he didn’t think of himself as a genius, and he saw the label as a burden, something it was impossible to live up to — but was also causing friction in the group, as it seemed that their contributions were being dismissed.
Again, I don’t agree with Mike’s position on any of this, but it is understandable. It’s also the case that Mike Love is, by nature, a very assertive and gregarious person, while Brian Wilson, for all that he took control in the studio, is incredibly conflict-avoidant and sensitive. From what I know of the two men’s personalities, and from things they’ve said, and from the session recordings that have leaked over the years, it seems entirely likely that Love will have seen himself as having reasonable criticisms, and putting them to Brian clearly with a bit of teasing to take the sting out of them; while Brian will have seen Love as mercilessly attacking and ridiculing the work that meant so much to him in a cruel and hurtful manner, and that neither will have understood at the time that that was how the other was seeing things.
Love’s criticisms intensified. Not of everything — he’s several times expressed admiration for “Heroes and Villains” and “Wonderful” — but in general he was not a fan of Parks’ lyrics. And his criticisms seemed to start to affect Brian. It’s difficult to say what Brian thinks about Parks’ lyrics, because he has a habit in interviews of saying what he thinks the interviewer wants to hear, and the whole subject of Smile became a touchy one for him for a long time, so in some interviews he has talked about how dazzlingly brilliant they are, while at other times he’s seemed to agree with Love, saying they were “Van Dyke Parks lyrics”, not “Beach Boys lyrics”. He may well sincerely think both at the same time, or have thought both at different times.
This came to a head with a session for the tag of “Cabinessence”:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “Cabinessence”]
Love insisted on having the line “over and over the crow flies uncover the cornfield” explained to him, and Brian eventually decided to call Van Dyke Parks and have him come to the studio.
Up to this point, Parks had no idea that there was anything controversial, so when Brian phoned him up and very casually said that Mike had a few questions about the lyrics, could he come down to the studio? He went without a second thought. He later said “The only person I had had any interchange with before that was Dennis, who had responded very favorably to ‘Heroes and Villains’ and ‘Surf’s Up’. Based on that, I gathered that the work would be approved. But then, with no warning whatsoever, I got that phone call from Brian. And that’s when the whole house of cards came tumbling down.”
Parks got to the studio, where he was confronted by an angry Mike Love, insisting he explain the lyrics. Now, as will be, I hope, clear from everything I’ve said, Parks and Love are very, very, *very* different people. Having met both men — albeit only in formal fan-meeting situations where they’re presenting their public face — I actually find both men very likeable, but in very different ways. Love is gregarious, a charmer, the kind of man who would make a good salesman and who people use terms like “alpha male” about. He’s tall, and has a casual confidence that can easily read as arrogance, and a straightforward sense of humour that can sometimes veer into the cruel.
Parks, on the other hand, is small, meticulously well-mannered and well-spoken, has a high, precise, speaking voice which probably reads as effeminate to the kind of people who use terms like “alpha male”, and the kind of devastating intelligence and Southern US attention to propriety which means that if he *wanted* to say something cruel about someone, the victim would believe themselves to have been complimented until a horrific realisation two days after the event.
In every way, from their politics to their attitudes to art versus commerce to their mannerisms to their appearance, Mike Love and Van Dyke Parks are utterly different people, and were never going to mix well. And Brian Wilson, who was supposed to be the collaborator for both of them, was not mediating between them, not even expressing an opinion — his own mental problems had reached the stage where he simply couldn’t deal with the conflict. Parks felt ambushed and hurt, Love felt angry, especially when Parks could not explain the literal meaning of his lyrics. Eventually Parks just said “I have no excuse, sir”, and left.
Parks later said “That’s when I lost interest. Because basically I was taught not to be where I wasn’t wanted, and I could feel I wasn’t wanted. It was like I had someone else’s job, which was abhorrent to me, because I don’t even want my own job. It was sad, so I decided to get away quick.”
Parks continued collaborating with Wilson, and continued attending instrumental sessions, but it was all wheelspinning — no significant progress was made on any songs after that point, in early December.
It was becoming clear that the album wasn’t going to be ready for its planned Christmas release, and it was pushed back to January, but Brian’s mental health was becoming worse and worse. One example that’s often cited as giving an insight into Brian’s mental state at the time is his reaction to going to the cinema to see John Frankenheimer’s classic science fiction horror film Seconds. Brian came in late, and the way the story is always told, when he was sat down the screen was black and a voice said from the darkness, “Hello Mr. Wilson”.
That moment does not seem to correspond with anything in the actual film, but he probably came in around the twenty-four minute mark, where the main character walks down a corridor, filmed in a distorted, hallucinatory manner, to be greeted:
[Excerpt: Seconds, 24:00]
But as Brian watched the film, primed by this, he became distressed by a number of apparent similarities to his life. The main character was going through death and rebirth, just as he felt he was. Right after the moment I just excerpted, Mr. Wilson is shown a film, and of course Brian was himself watching a film. The character goes to the beach in California, just like Brian. The character has a breakdown on a plane, just like Brian, and has to take pills to cope, and the breakdown happens right after this:
[Excerpt: Seconds, from about 44:22]
A studio in California? Just like where Brian spent his working days?
That kind of weird coincidence can be affecting enough in a work of art when one is relatively mentally stable, but Brian was not at all stable. By this point he was profoundly paranoid — and he may have had good reason to be. Some of Brian’s friends from this time period have insisted that Brian’s semi-estranged abusive father and former manager, Murry, was having private detectives watch him and his brothers to find evidence that they were using drugs.
If you’re in the early stages of a severe mental illness *and* you’re self-medicating with illegal drugs, *and* people are actually spying on you, then that kind of coincidence becomes a lot more distressing. Brian became convinced that the film was the work of mind gangsters, probably in the pay of Phil Spector, who were trying to drive him mad and were using telepathy to spy on him.
He started to bar people who had until recently been his friends from coming to sessions — he decided that Jules Siegel’s girlfriend was a witch and so Siegel was no longer welcome — and what had been a creative process in the studio degenerated into noodling and second-guessing himself. He also, with January having come and the album still not delivered, started doing side projects,  some of which, like his production of tracks for photographer Jasper Daily, seem evidence either of his bizarre sense of humour, or of his detachment from reality, or both:
[Excerpt: Jasper Daily, “Teeter Totter Love”]
As 1967 drew on, things got worse and worse. Brian was by this point concentrating on just one or two tracks, but endlessly reworking elements of them. He became convinced that the track “Fire” had caused some actual fires to break out in LA, and needed to be scrapped. The January deadline came and went with no sign of the album. To add to that, the group discovered that they were owed vast amounts of unpaid royalties by Capitol records, and legal action started which meant that even were the record to be finished it might become a pawn in the legal wrangling.
Parks eventually became exasperated by Brian — he said later “I was victimised by Brian Wilson’s buffoonery” — and he quit the project altogether in February after a row with Brian. He returned a couple of weeks later out of a sense of loyalty, but quit again in April.
By April, he’d been working enough with Lenny Waronker that Waronker offered him a contract with Warner Brothers as a solo artist — partly because Warners wanted some insight into Brian Wilson’s techniques as a hit-making producer.
To start with, Parks released a single, to dip a toe in the water, under the pseudonym “George Washington Brown”. It was a largely-instrumental cover version of Donovan’s song “Colours”, which Parks chose because after seeing the film Don’t Look Back, a documentary of Bob Dylan’s 1965 British tour, he felt saddened at the way Dylan had treated Donovan:
[Excerpt: George Washington Brown, “Donovan’s Colours”]
That was not a hit, but it got enough positive coverage, including an ecstatic review from Richard Goldstein in the Village Voice, that Parks was given carte blanche to create the album he wanted to create, with one of the largest budgets of any album released to that date. The result was a masterpiece, and very similar to the vision of Smile that Parks had had — an album of clever, thoroughly American music which had more to do with Charles Ives than the British Invasion:
[Excerpt: Van Dyke Parks, “The All Golden”]
But Parks realised the album, titled Song Cycle, was doomed to failure when at a playback session, the head of Warner Brothers records said “Song Cycle? So where are the songs?”
According to Parks, the album was only released because Jac Holzman of Elektra Records was also there, and took out his chequebook and said he’d release the album if Warners wouldn’t, but it had little push, apart from some rather experimental magazine adverts which were, if anything, counterproductive.
But Waronker recognised Parks’ talent, and had even written into Parks’ contract that Parks would be employed as a session player at scale on every session Waronker produced — something that didn’t actually happen, because Parks didn’t insist on it, but which did mean Parks had a certain amount of job security. Over the next couple of years Parks and Waronker co-produced the first albums by two of their colleagues from Waronker’s brains trust, with Parks arranging — Randy Newman:
[Excerpt: Randy Newman, “I Think It’s Going to Rain Today”]
And Ry Cooder:
[Excerpt: Ry Cooder, “One Meat Ball”]
Waronker would refer to himself, Parks, Cooder, and Newman as “the arts and crafts division” of Warners, and while these initial records weren’t very successful, all of them would go on to bigger things. Parks would be a pioneer of music video, heading up Warners’ music video department in the early seventies, and would also have a staggeringly varied career over the years, doing everything from teaming up again with the Beach Boys to play accordion on “Kokomo” to doing the string arrangements on Joanna Newsom’s album Ys, collaborating with everyone from U2 to Skrillex,  discovering Rufus Wainwright, and even acting again, appearing in Twin Peaks. He also continued to make massively inventive solo albums, releasing roughly one every decade, each unique and yet all bearing the hallmarks of his idiosyncratic style.
As you can imagine, he is very likely to come up again in future episodes, though we’re leaving him for now.
Meanwhile, the Beach Boys were floundering, and still had no album — and now Parks was no longer working with Brian, the whole idea of Smile was scrapped. The priority was now to get a single done, and so work started on a new, finished, version of “Heroes and Villains”, structured in a fairly conventional manner using elements of the Smile recordings.
The group were suffering from numerous interlocking problems at this point, and everyone was stressed — they were suing their record label, Dennis’ wife had filed for divorce, Brian was having mental health problems, and Carl had been arrested for draft dodging — though he was later able to mount a successful defence that he was a conscientious objector. Also, at some point around this time, Bruce Johnston seems to have temporarily quit the group, though this was never announced — he doesn’t seem to have been at any sessions from late May or early June through mid-September, and didn’t attend the two shows they performed in that time.
They were meant to have performed three shows, but even though Brian was on the board of the Monterey Pop Festival, they pulled out at the last minute, saying that they needed to deal with getting the new single finished and with Carl’s draft problems. Some or all of these other issues almost certainly fed into that, but the end result was that the Beach Boys were seen to have admitted defeat, to have handed the crown of relevance off to the San Francisco groups.
And even if Smile had been released, there were other releases stealing its thunder. If it had come out in December it would have been massively ahead of its time, but after the Beatles released Sgt Pepper it would have seemed like it was a cheap copy — though Parks has always said he believes the Beatles heard some of the Smile tapes and copied elements of the recordings, though I don’t hear much similarity myself.
But I do hear a strong similarity in “My World Fell Down” by Sagittarius, which came out in June, and which was largely made by erstwhile collaborators of Brian — Gary Usher produced, Glen Campbell sang lead, and Bruce Johnston sang backing vocals:
[Excerpt: Sagittarius, “My World Fell Down”]
Brian was very concerned after hearing that that someone *had* heard the Smile tapes, and one can understand why.
When “Heroes and Villains” finally came out, it was a great single, but only made number twelve in the charts. It was fantastic, but out of step with the times, and nothing could have lived up to the hype that had built up around it:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “Heroes and Villains”]
Instead of Smile, the group released an album called Smiley Smile, recorded in a couple of months in Brian’s home studio, with no studio musicians and no involvement from Bruce, other than the previously released singles, and with the production credited to “the Beach Boys” rather than Brian.
Smiley Smile has been unfairly dismissed over the years, but it’s actually an album that was ahead of its time. It’s a collection of stripped down versions of Smile songs and new fragments using some of the same motifs, recorded with minimal instrumentation. Some of it is on a par with the Smile material it’s based on:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “Wonderful”]
Some is, to my ears, far more beautiful than the Smile versions:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “Wind Chimes”]
And some has a fun goofiness which relates back to one of Brian’s discarded ideas for Smile, that it be a humour album:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “She’s Going Bald”]
The album was a commercial flop, by far the least successful thing the group had released to that point in the US, not even making the top forty when it came out in September, though it made the top ten in the UK, but interestingly it *wasn’t* a critical flop, at least at first.
While the scrapping of Smile had been mentioned, it still wasn’t widely known, and so for example Richard Goldstein, the journalist whose glowing review of “Donovan’s Colours” in the Village Voice had secured Van Dyke Parks the opportunity to make Song Cycle, gave it a review in the New York Times which is written as if Goldstein at least believes it *is* the album that had been promised all along, and he speaks of it very perceptively — and here I’m going to quote quite extensively, because the narrative about this album has always been that it was panned from the start and made the group a laughing stock:
“Smiley Smile hardly reads like a rock cantata. But there are moments in songs such as ‘With Me Tonight’ and ‘Wonderful’ that soar like sacred music. Even the songs that seem irrelevant to a rock-hymn are infused with stained-glass melodies. Wilson is a sound sculptor and his songs are all harmonious litanies to the gentle holiness of love — post-Christian, perhaps but still believing.
‘Wind Chimes’, the most important piece on the album, is a fine example of Brian Wilson’s organic pop structure. It contains three movements. First, Wilson sets a lyric and melodic mood (“In the late afternoon, you’re hung up on wind chimes”). Then he introduces a totally different scene, utilizing passages of pure, wordless harmony. His two-and-a-half minute hymn ends with a third movement in which the voices join together in an exquisite round, singing the words, “Whisperin’ winds set my wind chimes a-tinklin’.” The voices fade out slowly, like the bittersweet afternoon in question.
The technique of montage is an important aspect of Wilson’s rock cantata, since the entire album tends to flow as a single composition. Songs like ‘Heroes and Villains’, are fragmented by speeding up or slowing down their verses and refrains. The effect is like viewing the song through a spinning prism. Sometimes, as in ‘Fall Breaks and Back to Winter’ (subtitled “W. Woodpecker Symphony”), the music is tiered into contrapuntal variations on a sliver of melody. The listener is thrown into a vast musical machine of countless working gears, each spinning in its own orbit.”
That’s a discussion of the album that I hear when I listen to Smiley Smile, and the group seem to have been artistically happy with it, at least at first. They travelled to Hawaii to record a live album (with Brian, as Bruce was still out of the picture), taking the Baldwin organ that Brian used all over Smiley Smile with them, and performed rearranged versions of their old hits in the Smiley Smile style. When the recordings proved unusable, they recreated them in the studio, with Bruce returning to the group, where he would remain, with the intention of overdubbing audience noise and releasing a faked live album:
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “California Girls [Lei’d studio version]”]
The idea of the live album, to be called Lei’d in Hawaii, was scrapped, but that’s not the kind of radical reimagining of your sound that you do if you think you’ve made an artistic failure. Indeed, the group’s next album, Wild Honey, which came out in late 1967, is very much a successor to Smiley Smile in its stripped-down sound, but with a set of songs that have a certain amount of influence from the soul music that Carl and Mike were now listening to.
[Excerpt: The Beach Boys, “Wild Honey”]
The singles from “Wild Honey” were moderately successful, and it looked like the group were going to reinvent themselves, but then the critical consensus changed. First there was Jules Siegel’s article on Smile, titled “Goodbye Surfing, Hello God”, which had been intended for the Saturday Evening Post but had itself gone through endless delays, and which eventually came out in Cheetah magazine roughly a month after Smiley Smile came out, and which became the first draft of history as far as Smile was concerned — telling the story not of an album scrapped and reworked, but of Icarus soaring too close to the sun, while his bandmates pulled the feathers off. It reinforced all the “genius” stories that Wilson had found so upsetting, while implicitly making any new music that actually got released pale in comparison to a mythical album that had never been finished and which could take on any shape the listener imagined.
Meanwhile, Jann Wenner wrote an article in his new magazine Rolling Stone — a magazine which explicitly sided with San Francisco in the war between Frisco and LA, and which over the years would contribute to almost all the LA bands being critically sidelined or forgotten in the US, no matter how good they’d been — dismissing all the hype about the group and about Brian’s genius, and arguing that they were only a moderately good pop band, and not even that good live, and should stick to the fun stuff they knew and not try to play with the big boys.
And more or less overnight these two views became the sum total of American critical opinion of the Beach Boys — a mainstream opinion that dismissed them as frothy lightweight has-beens who’d made a few good singles but had been overtaken, and a more hipsterish, underground, version that said that Brian Wilson was a genius but he had been sabotaged by his bandmates and the proof of that genius had never been released, so you’d best just take it on trust.
Neither required any acknowledgement of any work the group might do in the future, any capacity of progress or relevance for them, or any reason to engage critically with any new work they did. Brian Wilson was permanently cast as either an overrated dilettante who believed his own press or a tragic victim sabotaged by his family; his bandmates, either way, as talentless hacks. And as anyone who has tried to talk about the Beach Boys online knows, that dual consensus remains largely in place today, irrespective of any actual qualities of the music.
At least for the moment, though, the group were still on a commercial and critical upswing in the UK, at a time when critical reputations were much less coupled than they are now, and when Mike and Bruce decided to drop in at the Beatles’ Christmas launch party for their new film, Magical Mystery Tour, they were treated as honoured guests, and invited to jam on stage with, depending on which version of events you believe, either John, Paul, and Ringo, the Bonzo Dog Doo-Dah Band, or some combination of all of the above.
And they had a new mutual acquaintance. A few days before, at the instigation of Dennis Wilson, the Beach Boys had met up with the Maharishi, who the Beatles had started seeing a couple of months earlier. Dennis himself didn’t remain impressed with the Maharishi for long, and went off looking for another guru to follow, but Mike Love became a devoted follower, as he is to this day, and two months later Mike Love would join the Beatles and Donovan on a retreat with the Maharishi in Rishikesh, in India.
What nobody could know at the time was that the songs the Beatles would write on that retreat would intersect horribly, in unpredictable ways, with Dennis Wilson’s search for a guru. Ways which would ultimately lead back to the house on Cielo Drive where Brian and Van Dyke first agreed to collaborate.
But that, I am glad to say, is a much darker story for another time.

26 thoughts on “Episode 153: “Heroes and Villains” by the Beach Boys

  1. David Vawter

    This one is especially bittersweet. As cringey as Mike Love can be, he’s 100% right about the music the Beach Boys made post-“Good Vibrations.” The quote that sums it up: “From his perspective, this was a partnership, and it was being turned into a dictatorship without him having been consulted.” I don’t know how anyone could say with a straight face that “Smile” is remotely as enjoyable to listen to as “Beach Boys Today,” “Summer Days (and Summer Nights!!) or “Pet Sounds.” Van Dyke Parks ruined the Beach Boys.

    1. Andrew Hickey

      See, for me, I would *infinitely* rather listen to Smile than to Today or Summer Days, even though I find those albums enjoyable enough. For me the stretch of work from Smile through to the Beach Boys Love You is possibly the best, most interesting, run of music by any major artist ever, and I think Parks’ contribution to Smile is outstanding. But I can still see Love’s perspective.

      1. David Vawter

        “Surf’s Up” is brilliant of course and what can you say about “Good Vibrations?” There’s no greater three minutes in the history of pop music. But “Do You Like Worms?” and the like sound to me like a guy trapped in his own head and trying way too hard. Better than ’68-’72 Stones? Or ’81-’87 Prince? That’s saying a lot. I agree the Beach Boys are major artists but the greatness ended with Pet Sounds. Although I do appreciate the bizarre, not-so-funhouse quality of Love You. What is your POV on “That’s Why God Made the Radio?”

      2. Andrew Hickey

        That’s Why God Made the Radio is the closest thing to a good Beach Boys album since LA (Light Album), and has a handful of excellent moments, but only a handful (and not the ones people point to, for the most part, which seem to be entirely Joe Thomas constructs pointing at the mythology of Brian, rather than having any real creative input from Brian or the other Beach Boys). A few glimmers of personality manage to emerge through the cracks in the carefully constructed Homogenised Beach Boys-Like Commercial Music-Style Product, but not enough that I’ve had any great desire to listen to it since about 2014.

  2. David Vawter

    Yes, the pro wrestler. Not to mention Jim Peterik, one of the ripest slices of purple-haired cheese in the whole dairy case (although I will confess that some of those Survivor tracks are a guilty pleasure). Still it’s hard not to smile when you hear all those harmonies in full flow. Sad that things went pear-shaped again between the cousins almost immediately afterward. I assume you know of Bob Lefsetz; he is a huge Beach Boys fan and has covered them in depth in his blog and podcasts.

  3. Tracy L Collier

    I found your podcast, invited by Seth Godin on his blog in mid June. I started at episode one and today I caught up!
    I’ve recommended it to more than 20 others, added significantly to my Spotify playlists, learned so much about a topic I thought I was knowledgeable in, and became a patreon supporter.
    Thanks for your extensive research and well executed podcast!

  4. Robert Morris

    The episode contained a great analysis of the musical concepts found in Smile, and of the reasons the project failed. I remember when the boxed set of the Smile sessions was released. One track in particular fascinated me: it is called “Vegetables: Fade”. It records the process of Wilson arriving at an arrangement of the violins during the roughly 30 second fade-out of the Vegetables track. At the end he converges on a hauntingly beautiful arrangement where the violins ‘sustain’ a single note, making them sound like an organ. The result stands on its own as a lovely little ditty. The problem is, when you go back and listen to the track of the finished song, the instruments during the fade are completely drowned out by the vocals (which to my taste are not the best example of Beach Boy harmonies). To me this suggests that Wilson was still at this time at the height of his creative talents, but lacked the discipline to integrate the fragments he was producing into a satisfying finished product.

  5. Michael Ross

    The next-to-last time I met VDP, he was living in what can be described as a mansion in Hancock Park, which was off the so-called Miracle Mile in Los Angeles. The house was owned by the mother (or grandmother) of his lovely then-wife Durrie. All they had to do to keep the residence he told me (as I recall) was to pay for gardening. Unfortunately, the lawns were as big as football fields. At any rate, he played me several records of Trinidadian steel band music – later, he produced a wonderful album by the Esso Trinidad Steel Band. I remember Van Dyke as truly embodying the cliches of “a gentleman and a scholar” as well as “not of this world.”

    (btw… the last time I saw him was during the recording of his single “The Eagle & I” – what I remember most about that encounter was drinking the best Bloody Mary of my life.)

  6. Wilson Smith

    It is not unusual for someone suffering from paranoia or stoned on psychedelics to think a song or other media are referring to them. I think of the scene in “Imagine” where John Lennon greets a disturbed fan who insists that the singer’s songs are speaking to him. Under psychedelics, one might believe that he or she is being referenced in a song, but after the trip is over, this can pass. For Brian Wilson to watch, without being stoned, a scene like the one in “Seconds” with its multitude of references that coincidently align with things that mirror his own life, the effect must have been terrifying.

  7. Soar

    I have to say I struggled with this episode – and, to a degree, the next one on the Turtles.

    The series is masterful, but there was a lot going on in 1967 and this seems like a lot of time to spend on a group/artists who’s best work has been covered in depth in fairly recent episodes.

    However, we must all indulge our personal passions So, if a Beach Boys lover wants to propose the Smile sessions as a seminal moment in the musical ferment of 1967, then so be it.

    1. Andrew Hickey

      You didn’t “have to say” that at all. Nobody is forcing you to listen to episodes on things you’re not interested in. And certainly nobody is forcing you to leave comments saying so. There are roughly a million other podcasts you could be listening to dealing with other topics you might find more congenial.
      Of course I apologise if someone *has* got a gun to your head, but otherwise we have different definitions of what you had to do.

      1. David Vawter

        Is there a place to give “two thumbs up” to this response?? 😉 Reminds me of an anecdote I read about some fan approaching an elderly Cary Grant in a restaurant while he was in the middle of eating. The fan initiated whatever his request was with the phrase, “I hate to ask you but –” at which point Mr Grant shut him down by saying, “oh dear, you should never do anything you hate.”

      2. SOAR

        Hmm, ok. Context is everything,

        I have to say, because it can’t be said too often, in my opinion, The History Of Rock Music in 500 Songs is a master work. And master works such as this come along very rarely. It’s truly epic.

        I have to say, because it needs to be said, in my opinion, it is the civic duty of all listeners to back The History Of Rock Music In 500 Songs on Patreon. A work of this stature must be supported and nurtured for the greater good of us all.

        In the context of the above, I have to say, picking on a colloquialism feels a little… unnecessary. I expected a simple “no” or “your wrong”. And telling me to listen to other podcasts! What am I going to listen to? THORMI500S throws Vanatablack shade on every other podcast in the known universe.

  8. Andrew Hickey

    It’s not the colloquialism. It’s a more general thing. Giving unrequested negative feedback on someone’s work, especially work that’s already out there and available to the public, serves no purpose other than to let the creator know that you don’t like the work — in other words, it serves no purpose other than to make the creator feel bad.
    (This is one reason, incidentally, why I beg people not to tag artists I write about when talking about my work. They didn’t ask to hear my opinions of them.)

    Saying “I like your work” to a creator — great. Makes everyone feel good.
    GIving specifically-requested negative feedback to someone who’s asked for it — great! You’re helping them do better work!
    Saying “I don’t like this work” or “I don’t like this episode” or “I wish they’d done X differently” *in a review, for other audience members, or on your own social media* — great! Talking about what you like and don’t like about a work is a good thing to do. And if the creator seeks out such reviews, and wants your opinions, then how they feel about what you say is on them.

    But telling people what you dislike about their work, when that’s not been requested, and when it’s already been released in its final form, is just causing hurt for no reason, especially when you’ve had no previous interaction. It’s the equivalent of walking up to a stranger in the street and saying “God, you’re ugly!” and then walking off. What are they meant to do with that information other than feel bad about it? The episode’s already out there, you’ve already listened to it, there’s nothing to be done.

    Now, it’s not an unforgivable thing to do — I’ve done it myself in the past, many years ago, though I feel bad about it now and try not to do it any more — and for some reason there seems to be a general social consensus that giving “feedback” or “constructive criticism” is somehow a good thing. But it’s not a consensus that’s shared by any writer, musician, artist, or comedian I know (and I know a lot). Every one of them I know says it can wreck their day. It’s basically a complete stranger coming up to them and insulting them.

    Now *I* make an exception for things like factual errors, accessibility issues, use of the wrong terms for minority groups and so on. I want to be told when I get those things wrong so I can fix them and/or apologise and do better next time, because it’s important to me not to cause actual harm with my work and to mitigate any harm already caused. Even those still provoke a little bit of a negative reaction in me because it’s never *nice* to be told you’ve hurt someone or made a mistake, but those things are necessary. Some people don’t even make an exception for those things.

    Just… think about your comments. Think about what the best possible outcome of you leaving such a comment is. Think about the real hurt such comments can cause to the real person at the other end of them, and then ask yourself if it’s really worth leaving them.

    1. Tim Soar

      I have thought for a while on your reply to this. The excellent Incredible String Band episode brought this into some focus too.

      I think, and this is just my personal view, without the space for ‘negative’ criticism, positive criticism becomes meaningless.

      You are quite right, as a creative person it is very hard to be objective about anything other than completely positive feedback. But – back to the Incredible String Band episode – when there is no tension, creative flabbiness can set in.

      But to be absolutely clear, there is no sign of creative flabbiness the show!

      Keep it up.

      1. Andrew Hickey

        I have typed and deleted several much, much, ruder replies than this one. Because they would be giving you uninvited negative criticism.
        Which is the key point. *Uninvited*. Negative criticism *when asked for*, *from a collaborator or trusted first reader who has a track record and whose biases you can account for* is useful.
        Negative “criticism” from a random stranger, when uninvited, is just abuse pure and simple. You were just unutterably rude, and you’re desperately trying to come up with some sort of intellectual argument for why rudeness is OK when it’s you doing it. It isn’t.

  9. JOHN H.

    Episode #154 in this series was my first and I loved it! I’m at the website now to learn what other songs you did. I wondered what you could talk about for an hour and a half on one song. Now I get it. I loved the way you put “Heroes and Villains” not just in the context of the BeachBoys but also brought in so many other artists and songs. I was 20 when “Heroes and Villains” came out and thought I was really into music, But I learned a lot from this episode. I’m looking forward to catching up. Thanks a lot for doing this.

  10. Michael Spitler

    I went to High School in Austin, TX with Terry Gilkyson’s grandson, Cisco. His mother is Eliza Gilkyson, and she’s a singer-songwriter, herself. She’s based in New Mexico now, still making music. I don’t know what happened to Cisco. Love the podcast! Ciao!

    1. David Vawter

      Not to mention (although I am doing so here) her brother Tony, member of Lone Justice as well as Billy Zoom’s replacement in the greatest of all American punk bands, X.

Leave a Reply